Construction has shown the value of designing out risk. David England explains why every safety professional should take note
Image credit: Shutterstock/Parilov
It has been 11 years since the second reissue of the UK’s construction regulations. The Construction (Design and Management) Regulations of 2015 built on the successes of the original 1994 and subsequent 2007 versions.
There can be little argument that the introduction of specific legislation for the industry has had a positive effect on the safety and health of construction workers in the UK in general. And, with safety having been at the forefront of people’s minds for more than three decades now, it has had the chance to expand into welfare too – particularly important considering the real risk to mental wellbeing that still pervades the construction industry.
Safety throughout the project
The 2015 revision to the legislation followed a slightly different path to that of the previous incarnations. They were mainly concerned with safety as a fundamental, having regard to the appalling accident rate in construction at the time. The 2015 revision, however, focused on reeling safety back to the very start of a project. The CDM Coordinator (CDMC) from the 2007 law – whose main purpose was to ensure the construction phase of the project was carried out safely – was replaced with the principal designer (PD), a role very much focused on inherent safety throughout the project.
Many in the industry in the UK mourned the passing of the CDMC: it was a role that in many ways took away any uncertainty about safety regulations per se. Clients and contractors alike could rely on a CDMC’s knowledge of health and safety to ‘keep a steady ship’ during the construction phase. Indeed, today there are still projects that call for a “CDM Advisor”, a role with no formal function other than to advise on health, safety, and welfare. Such is the desire to ensure health and safety during the construction phase is properly overseen.
A different line of thinking
The PD ushered in a different line of thinking, and one that we could learn from in other areas of health and safety management. The PD role is not one of design, nor of management. It is about ensuring the principles of safety are adopted and provided for at the very outset of a construction project. The PD supports the design team in a role designated by, and for, the client. The PD’s responsibility should be to the general principles of prevention rather than any particular financial or partisan pressure. This was a conscious decision at the time of updating the legislation from the 2007 version. It was done in recognition that the person with the chequebook – i.e., the client – is the one in a position to make financial judgements about all aspects of a project, including safety.
It also recognizes the requirement of Section 6 of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 regarding design. Section 3 (a) reads “to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that the article is so designed and constructed as to be safe and without risks to health when properly used”. It may be stretch to imagine an office block to be considered an ‘article’, but the principle remains. Anything we design to be used needs to be designed with the safety of the people who make it, use it, and ultimately dispose of it in mind. Even further, Section 3 (c) requires ‘adequate information’ about how the article should be operated and maintained; a requirement that found its way 20 years later into CDM 1994 as the health and safety file.
A blend of two roles
In essence, the PD role is not strictly a technical role; nor is it predominately a safety role. It is, in fact, a blend of the two. And this is where the 2015 regulations perhaps created their greatest challenge. Technical design experts were not, by and large, experts in safety, and vice versa. This meant that, in the main, PDs were represented by organizations rather than individuals, as had been the case with CDM Coordinators, many of whom were sole operators. Unfortunately, this led to the current situation where design organizations often take on the role of PD without fully understanding – or implementing – the legislative requirements, either in the spirit or letter of the law.
This is a shame, because effective application of the PD role in virtually any construction project can prove highly beneficial. The book An Effective Strategy for Safe Design in Engineering and Construction, demonstrated how a PD could be invaluable in the design process by conducting design reviews at the feasibility, concept, and delivery stages. A report commissioned by Britain’s Health and Safety Executive, Implementation of the Principal Designer Role within CDM 2015 found that the PD role offered significant benefits. Among them were:
- Early consideration of design / health and safety.
- Better coordination and communication between different teams / duty holders.
- Improved integration of safety and design.
- More understanding / awareness of design risk.
- Improved project information.
All of these factors can benefit the bottom line: by removing the need for rework or redesign later in the project, when key decisions have been made or critical paths are already in play. The Get It Right Initiative (GIRI), a leading group of industry experts, estimated that between £10 and £25 billion could be saved by eliminating error in construction projects in the UK. In their report Improving value by eliminating error, the primary root cause of error in construction projects was identified as ‘management and planning’, giving credence to the old saying that failing to plan is planning to fail.
Simplicity
So how can this regulatory environment centred on the construction industry help us in the day-to-day safety of other sectors? How do very specific roles, defined in bespoke UK safety law, apply to general health and safety management? The answer is simplicity: start at the beginning of any situation and plan a way through it, identifying the ‘what if’ possibilities before they become real world issues.
Construction regulation in the UK is, unfortunately, often seen as simply a requirement for hard hats and toe caps. This is far from the truth. The general principles of prevention require a train of thought about any safety issue. Can the hazard be removed or replaced? Can we automate or isolate the process? Is there a technical solution available? Rather than assessing risk when the machines are already running, or the chemical plant is already producing, we should be looking at what issues might become threats to safety before we switch on, or employ personnel, or open our new factory.
Often, this can be done at the design stage, whether we are designing a new warehouse, office space, or workshop layout. We should not only be concerned with building regulations, or material quality, or machinery type – we should be fully integrating with the various groups of people who will be interfacing with the work space in whatever way.
Holistic concept
Safety should be a cohesive process from concept to disposal, with operation being just one part of that process. Workplace safety is a holistic concept, one that UK construction regulations have endeavoured to cultivate for more than 30 years.

David England works as an independent consultant in safety, risk management, and compliance. He is also a subject matter expert for NEBOSH, helping to deliver the diploma and construction papers, as well as being an external examiner for the University of Hull.
David is a frequent presenter at health and safety shows and for the NEBOSH Alumni. He is a Fellow of both the International Institute of Risk and Safety Management and the Institute of Construction Management.
