ESG: Beyond reporting

Louise Hosking at The Choice Chain explores how companies can build organisational capability into their ESG strategy.

Increasingly, investors, customers, regulators and society expect organisations to consider environmental, social and governance (ESG) impacts alongside financial performance. These growing expectations have made ESG one of the most significant influences on how organisations seek to create and demonstrate long-term value. According to McKinsey’s 2019 report, Five ways that ESG creates value, it can benefit people, communities and long-term organisational performance.

For large organisations ESG reporting has increasingly become part of corporate life. For many SMEs, however, ESG begins very differently. It often starts with a customer questionnaire, tender requirement or a request from a major client asking for information they have never been asked to provide before – yet organisations are approaching this journey from very different starting points.

Some have spent years embedding ESG into their culture, governance and operations. For others, it is a reaction to growing expectations from customers, particularly within global supply chains, while balancing commercial pressures, limited resources and competing priorities. Neither position is inherently right or wrong; they simply reflect different stages of organisational maturity.

Perhaps the more interesting question is no longer whether organisations are engaging with ESG, but how they develop the capability to make it part of the way they operate. Organisational maturity is not simply reflected in the sophistication of reporting, but also in its ability to make better decisions consistently.

Three realities

The current ESG landscape appears to reflect three realities:

First, many organisations have invested significantly in ESG capability and reporting, improving transparency and encouraging more consistent consideration of environmental, social and governance issues.

Second, expectations continue to grow across value chains. Larger organisations increasingly request ESG information from suppliers to meet reporting requirements and stakeholder expectations.

Third, organisations are responding from very different levels of capability, capacity and organisational maturity. Many already understand ESG. The challenge is often less about awareness than having the capability, capacity and confidence to embed it effectively. Recognising these different starting points shifts the conversation from judgement to development. Rather than telling suppliers what good looks like, leading organisations build capability through collaboration, shared learning and proportionate expectations.

Moving beyond reporting

Reporting remains an essential part of effective governance. The purpose remains the same: to improve transparency, accountability and informed decision-making. However, reporting alone does not transform organisations. Too often, reporting becomes where progress stalls.

The organisations making the greatest progress use ESG to shape purpose, strategy and decisions, influencing priorities, investment and resilience. Rather than asking, “How do we complete the report?” organisations should ask, “How should this influence the way we run the business?”

This represents the difference between organisations using ESG primarily to satisfy external expectations and those using it to shape how the organisation creates long-term value.

Aligning ambition with capability

I’ve found organisations are rarely held back by commitment. More often, they struggle to translate ambition into everyday practice. Boards rightly set ambitious direction. Executive teams then face the responsibility of turning that ambition into something operationally achievable.

Where expectations significantly outpace capability, organisations can find themselves producing increasing amounts of reporting while struggling to embed lasting change. This is not a failure of intent. It is often a reflection of organisational capability.

As organisations respond to external reporting demands, effort can become focused on immediate customer requirements before ESG is aligned with organisational purpose, strategy and operating model. Boards and executives should recognise current capability, agree the desired direction and establish a realistic pathway between the two.

Attempting to adopt governance approaches beyond the organisation’s current capability can unintentionally create reactive behaviours, short-term decision-making and a continuing reliance on reporting rather than improvement.

Stronger value chains through stronger capability

This challenge is particularly evident across global value chains. Larger organisations increasingly request ESG information from suppliers to meet reporting obligations and stakeholder expectations.

However, many suppliers, particularly SMEs, are balancing these requests alongside limited resources, operational demands and day-to-day commercial realities. The question therefore becomes broader than data collection.

So how do larger organisations help their suppliers succeed? The strongest value chains won’t simply collect more information. They will build capability throughout the chain, recognising that long-term value depends on collective progress rather than individual compliance.

Progress in ESG is not simply about raising expectations. It is also about enabling organisations to meet them.

Responding to increasing customer data requests can divert smaller organisations from building the capability needed to achieve meaningful ESG outcomes and resilient value chains.

ESG as an integrated way of thinking

Perhaps one of the most significant developments in recent years is that ESG is no longer the responsibility of a single function.

Finance, procurement, operations, human resources, health and safety, sustainability and governance all contribute to ESG outcomes. Equally, environmental, social and governance considerations rarely exist in isolation. They influence one another continuously.

When people understand purpose and feel valued, they are more likely to contribute ideas, challenge constructively and solve complex problems. Well-governed organisations are better equipped to manage risk, enabling both positive and negative outcomes to be understood. Strong ESG performance contributes to long-term social and financial value.

The opportunity is therefore not to manage these as separate workstreams, but to recognise their interdependence when making decisions.

Freedom within a frame

One lesson repeatedly emerges from organisations operating internationally: consistency matters and so does flexibility of approach.

Global frameworks, whether informed by recognised standards or organisational principles, provide an important baseline. Yet successful implementation depends upon allowing sufficient flexibility for local teams to apply those principles within different operational, cultural and regulatory contexts.

International standards such as ISO 9001, ISO 14001, ISO 45001 and ISO 31000 illustrate this well. They provide a common framework while allowing organisations to apply them in ways that reflect their context, culture and stage of development.

This provides ‘freedom within a frame’. The frame provides consistency of purpose, direction and priorities. Without it, organisations and jurisdictions pull in different directions, risk increases and maintaining the system consumes resources.

The freedom allows those operating within the frame to apply judgement, use local knowledge, build ownership and continuously improve their piece of the whole.

Sustainable change is rarely achieved through documentation alone. It comes from building capability and following an achievable pathway for organisational development.

Freedom within a frame

ESG will continue to evolve. Reporting expectations will develop. Regulations will change. New standards will emerge. But perhaps the organisations that gain the greatest long-term value will not simply be those producing increasingly sophisticated reports.

They will be those translating ambition into everyday practice, helping people, partners and suppliers grow together through more integrated decisions that create value for nature, people, society and the economy.

Ultimately, organisational maturity is measured not by the quality of a report, but by the quality of the decisions it helps organisations make.

Throughout my work developing the Choice Chain, I have become increasingly convinced that sustainable organisations are shaped by the cumulative effect of the choices they make every day. ESG provides an opportunity to make those choices more integrated, more transparent and more purposeful.

Process over purpose

Reporting helps us understand where we are. Purpose tells us where we want to go. It is the quality of our choices that ultimately determines whether we get there.


1-ISJ- ESG: Beyond reporting

Louise Hosking is Founder of the The Choice Chain. You can connect with her on LinkedIn here and find out more at the website here. You can also read and subscribe to Louise’s Choice Chain Series on Substack here.

3-ISJ- ESG: Beyond reporting





Share this content

Latest Issue

Connect with us

Free digital subscription

Receive the latest breaking news straight to your inbox