High tech tools – human hands

Keith Hole, Director, TSM UK Consulting and Lucy Pritchard, Head of Health and Safety at Shoreham Port reveal why safety leadership basics still matter in an AI world.

“In this world, nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes,” Benjamin Franklin said in 1789. To this I would add one more thing, and that’s change. In fact, from a health and safety perspective change is one of our greatest constants.

While health and safety professionals battle an ever-widening remit – including wellbeing, environment, fire safety, security as well as traditional health and safety – they are also facing a greater challenge around technology, and specifically AI which they need to adapt to.

You may say ask what the problems is as AI can help manage your workload and spot things you might have missed before, but the key to doing so effectively is to integrate them into your processes while retaining the practical human-led side of safety leadership.

One of the mixed blessings of AI-use in a health and is the sheer volume of data – safety alerts, alarms, AI-derived root cause analyses, to name just a few. I would however say that this isn’t a new challenge.

For example, Piper Alpha 1988, Air France Flight 447 and Deepwater Horizon 2010, all these incidents had root cause issues such as cognitive overload from alarms and alerts, alarm flooding causing confusion, unreliable data and alerts that were simply disabled due to frequent false alarms. 

So, what have we learnt from these events that we still need to keep in mind? Firstly, we need to balance the benefits of predictive maintenance, enhanced root cause analysis, operational efficiency and evidence-based decision making with the risks of false alerts, confusing interfaces, and cognitive overload or alarm fatigue.  Secondly, and perhaps more importantly, we need to think of technology as a tool and not a cure.

Technology as a tool, not cure

While digital twins and AI-driven predictive analytics can provide a powerful safety net, they are not a substitute for a well-formed and robust safety culture. In order to use these tools to your best advantage you need to think about:

Augmentation over replacement
AI can enhance visibility of hazards and risk, but effective leadership drives accountability.

The invisible risk
Sensors can detect physical hazards, but culture prevents behavioural failure.

Algorithm limits
Machines can process data, but you need a human touch to provide context and moral judgment.

The risk of augmentation bias

Augmentation bias is the tendency to favour suggestions from automated systems even when they contradict our own senses.

How many times have you relied on your phone to tell you what the weather is doing rather than looking out the window or blindly followed your sat-nav and ended up in a dead end?

While this might have just resulted in you forgetting your umbrella, or being late; in the world of health and safety relying too heavily on what the AI systems are telling you and ignoring what your team on the ground have to say could be the difference between everyone going home safe at the end of the day or having to make a very difficult phone call to a colleague’s loved ones. 

Fighting digital tech complacency

The fight against digital complacency is real. The risk of over-focusing on what the tech is telling us can allow blind spots to creep in as we stop questioning and trusting what we see, hear and recognise.  This can also lead workers to stop critically thinking about what they are doing and seeing and instead wait to be told what to do. In a safety critical role, this can lead to serious incidents.

So what’s the solution? One option is to carefully think about the role that AI and automation play in your team. Position AI as a co-pilot rather than the pilot. This can give you the space to focus on the central pillars of an effective safety culture such as building trust, effective communication and real, visible, felt leadership. 

Get out from behind the keyboard and be present, in fact be actively present. Show up for your team and demonstrate to them the benefits of the support AI can bring and they can welcome it like another team member instead of feeling threatened or like their views no longer matter.

Human-led but AI-enabled

As a safety leader, you have a key role to play in setting the culture and direction for your team and company and that can only happen if you are firmly in the driving seat.  AI is a tool that can be used to great effect but only if it forms part of an overall strategy and has the right leader behind it.

Remember, the future of health and safety is human-led but AI-enabled.

Share this content

Latest Issue

Connect with us

Free digital subscription

Receive the latest breaking news straight to your inbox