Managing risk beyond borders

Emma Evans examines how legal requirements can shape risk assessments across global operations

Many organisations operate across multiple jurisdictions, employ culturally diverse workforces and deliver complex projects involving contractors, suppliers and partners from around the world.

The challenge is no longer simply understanding local health and safety requirements; it is creating a consistent approach to risk management that can work across different regulatory systems, industries and cultures.

While every country has its own legal framework, the fundamentals of effective risk management remain remarkably consistent. Successful organisations will identify hazards early, understand their risks, implement effective controls and continually learn from experience.

A challenge is understanding how different approaches to risk assessment complement each other, and how to create a safety culture that goes beyond compliance.

The United Kingdom

In the UK, the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974, and The Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999, provide strong examples of a goal-setting approach to health and safety management. In addition, the Health and Safety Executive’s (HSE) HSG65 framework is based around the four-stage Plan–Do–Check–Act cycle, which encourages duty holders to establish robust management systems, assess risks proportionately and continually improve its performance.

The strength of this approach is flexibility. Rather than prescribe a single method for every organisation, UK legislation expects employers to understand the foreseeable – and material – risks associated with their own activities and implement controls that are ‘suitable and sufficient’. This allows businesses to innovate, and adapt their approach as technology, working practices and operational risks evolve.

A goal-setting approach, in my view, does still place a significant responsibility on leadership. It requires organisations to have competent people, effective systems and a culture where risks can be openly discussed and challenged.

A written risk assessment (a legal requirement in the UK when you employ more than five employees) will not create a safe workplace by itself. This is, of course, important to demonstrate compliance and your appreciation of risk, but it is only when the significant findings and control measures contained within it are adequately communicated, shared, and known, together with effective decisions, behaviours and actions of leaders, that determine whether risk is effectively controlled.

The USA

The USA takes a slightly different approach, with many areas of health and safety regulation in certain areas being more prescriptive. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) establishes detailed requirements for controlling specific hazards, providing employers with clear expectations regarding minimum standards. This applies for things, including lockout/tagout (LOTO) procedures, electrical safety, fall protection, chemicals and excavations.

With LOTO, for example, in industries involving machinery maintenance, unexpected energisation can result in severe injury or fatality. OSHA requires employers to establish formal procedures to isolate energy sources, apply locks and tags, train employees and regularly verify that controls remain effective.

It is considered this type of prescriptive approach can provide better clarity and consistency, particularly in high-risk activities where there is little tolerance for failure. It demonstrates the value of having clear, non-negotiable controls for certain hazards.

However, Deepwater Horizon in 2010 still showed that even with extensive procedures and regulatory requirements, it cannot replace what part is needed by effective leadership and a strong safety culture. The explosion on the offshore drilling rig killed 11 workers, injuring 17 others, and resulted in one of the largest environmental disasters in history. Investigations identified failures in risk assessment, but also in effective decision-making, communication and process safety management.

The lessons from Deepwater Horizon are relevant to leaders worldwide. Compliance with procedures is essential, but it is not enough. As part of its approach to effective risk management – organisations must create environments where employees feel able to raise concerns, where operational pressures are balanced against safety considerations, and where leaders actively seek assurance that controls are working in practice.

Middle East

The Middle East provides another important perspective on global risk management. Over recent years – countries across the Gulf region have, and continue to, experience significant growth in construction, energy, transport and infrastructure projects. These developments often involve multinational contractors, international supply chains and workforces representing dozens of nationalities.

In this environment, consistency, and effective risk management, can be critical. Many organisations operating in the region have adopted ISO 45001 as a framework for establishing internationally recognised occupational health and safety management systems. ISO 45001 provides a common language for risk management, helping organisations align leadership expectations, worker participation, auditing processes and continual improvement activities across different locations.

For major projects in countries such as United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia and Qatar, a standardised approach can help address some of the challenges associated with large, diverse workforces. Effective communication, competence management and worker engagement become essential elements of risk control, particularly where language, cultural expectations and local practices may vary.

Lessons for leaders

Lessons for safety leaders (especially those on a global stage) are that there may not be only a single perfect model of safety or risk management. Goal setting systems encourage organisations to think critically about their risks. Prescriptive standards provide clarity for controlling specific hazards. International management systems create consistency across borders.

Each approach has value, and most effective organisations combine these strengths whilst meeting the legal requirements of the relevant jurisdiction.

Therefore, modern safety leadership may be less about choosing between compliance and flexibility, and more about creating a mature risk management culture, and one where senior leaders ensure that health and safety is integrated into business decision-making, investment choices and operational planning.


1-ISJ- Managing risk beyond borders

Emma Evans is Health and Safety Partner at Bexley Beaumont. She is a solicitor specialising in health and safety law and works with SMEs and large corporate PLCs, providing both non-contentious, advisory services and reactive, contentious legal advice and representation.

Emma works mainly with the construction, real estate, manufacturing, rail and housing sectors and is a passionate advocate for ESG, building safety, mental health and wellbeing and leadership.


Share this content

Latest Issue

Connect with us

Free digital subscription

Receive the latest breaking news straight to your inbox