Andrew Slater speaks to IHSJ about PPE decontamination misconceptions, the barriers preventing wider adoption of best practice and the operational improvements fire services are demanding.
From your perspective, what are the biggest misconceptions that still exist around PPE contamination and decontamination within the fire service?
I think some of the misconceptions are around understanding the standards. The reality is that organisations should be clear about their position. A product, process or service is either compliant with an NFPA standard or certified to it; simply stating that you are ‘aligned’ with a standard does not provide the same level of assurance or independent verification.
I think the misconception is around understanding the standards and what they actually mean. People often ask, “How clean is clean?” But we shouldn’t really use the word “clean”. The question should be: how effectively is contamination being removed?
Without wanting to sound disparaging towards other suppliers or competitors and people like Robbie Burns would attest to this, some organisations are very aloof with their data. They’ll say, “It definitely decontaminates”, but they won’t provide documentation from a notified body.
For example, I can’t just send something to a company around the corner to get the results I want.You take a contaminated garment, clean it and then test it again to prove how much contamination has been removed and to what level.
Testing should be conducted by recognised independent organisations such as UL, using robust methodologies that can objectively verify performance and contamination removal.
The industry needs greater transparency. If a supplier claims a process removes contamination, that claim should be supported by independently verified test data using recognised laboratories and repeatable methodologies.
What practical barriers are preventing firefighters from decontaminating kit after every exposure and how can those barriers be removed?
The barriers are simple: logistics and cost. Even if a process was 100% effective, no authority can afford to spend £130-plus every single time a firefighter attends an incident.
The guidance is that kit should be cleaned and decontaminated after exposure, but it’s simply not practical at that cost.
At present, many authorities are paying considerably less per item or per ensemble for their existing cleaning and decontamination processes. As a result, absorbing a significant increase in cost across an entire PPE fleet can be extremely challenging.
Then there’s the logistical issue. Most authorities issue two sets of kit. If you’re a busy authority, you can easily go through both sets before the first set comes back. Then what happens? You need pool stock. But pool stock requires capital investment and authorities don’t have unlimited budgets.
If turnaround times aren’t met, they need even more pool stock.
Many people talk about contamination, far fewer understand: Turnaround times; pool stock requirements; asset visibility; fleet management and cost of ownership.
There is growing awareness of standards. How well equipped are UK fire services to meet those expectations and where do you see the most significant gaps in current decontamination and asset-management processes?
Some authorities are very well versed in this. Hampshire is a good example and there are others as well. A lot of their specifications already reflect the importance of NFPA standards because there are areas where current EN standards don’t fully cover certain aspects of protection.
When I speak to people in the industry, including scientists and researchers who specialise in this area, the general thinking is that UK standards will have to become much more aligned with NFPA standards. NFPA 1851 has now become NFPA 1850 and if you’re compliant with NFPA 1850, you know you’re meeting those minimum standards of performance.
Compliance with NFPA 1850 provides a recognised framework for the care, maintenance, inspection and retirement of PPE.
Another gap is having a service that can genuinely provide decontamination to a recognised standard and prove it through independent verification. The second major gap is logistics, specifically asset tracking, turnaround times and KPIs.
What does an effective, scalable decontamination model look like in practice?
First of all, it needs a very robust IT system with live tracking.
The key thing is that the process must be simple for the firefighter. If a firefighter comes off a job, they should be able to use an app, press a few buttons and trigger collection of their kit. If you make that process simple, they’ll do it and it will help drive better behaviours.
What does a good system look like? The app triggers collection, the firefighter puts the kit in a bag and walks away. Within that day, or by the next morning, the bag is collected. The firefighter gets a notification that it’s been collected. When it arrives at the facility, they get another notification. If repairs are needed, they get notified. Once the cleaning and decontamination process is complete, they get another update.
The firefighter should be able to track their kit throughout the entire process.
The system also needs to be flexible because every fire authority operates differently. A firefighter may work at one station this week and another next week. If their kit is in the system, they should be able to redirect delivery to a different station if needed.
This issue is clearly personal for you as well as professional, with your son serving as a firefighter. How has that shaped your views on contamination risks?
Hugely. I’ve been in this industry for 20 years and my son has been a firefighter for more than five years. Several years ago one of the things I realised was that we needed to do more education around contamination.
That’s often down to budgets, resources and competing priorities rather than a lack of interest. Authorities are at different stages of their contamination-control journey.
I would speak to my son and ask things like, “Do you still put your gloves inside your helmet?” and he’d say yes. Well, you’re putting one of the most contaminated items inside something that sits on your head and close to your face.
When you listen to people such as Robbie Burns, who has cancer, and researchers such as Professor Anna Stec, who have highlighted the increased cancer risks faced by firefighters, it reinforces how serious this issue is.
I’m forever telling my son to wash his hands before eating, wash his hands before going to the toilet, remove contaminated kit as quickly as possible and pay attention to how he dons and doffs PPE.
For me, this isn’t just about selling a product or a service. It’s about helping to create a culture where contamination control becomes second nature, reducing exposure risks and improving the long-term health and wellbeing of firefighters.
Ultimately, standards are important, but they are only a means to an end. The objective is reducing firefighter exposure to harmful contaminants and improving long-term health outcomes.
